Citadel

Situation

A project that is failing

0:00Listen0:00

The situation

The thing you have been working on is not working. You have been telling yourself for weeks that it would turn around. It hasn't. The numbers are not where they should be. The energy is not what it was. People who were enthusiastic are quietly stepping back. You have to decide whether to keep going, change course, or shut it down. The decision has been deferred long enough that the deferral itself is now part of the problem.

The move

The reserve clause was supposed to be attached. I will pursue this — circumstances permitting. If you attached it, the current situation is the clause activating. If you did not, you are in the position of having staked your identity on an outcome that the universe did not deliver, and the work of unbinding is now also yours to do.

The dichotomy. Up to you: the next decision, the next conversation, the conduct you bring to whatever you choose. Not up to you: the past months of work, what people will say about the project, whether the thing was viable to begin with. Two of these are in column one. The rest is data, not material.

The Stoic action discipline is unusually clear here. Kathēkon — appropriate action — is the work you do given your nature, your station, and your circumstances. Your circumstances have changed. Yesterday's appropriate action may not be today's. The willingness to recognise this without conflating it with failure is much of the work.

Source grounding

Marcus, Meditations 5.20: the impediment to action advances action. The failing project is the obstacle. Acting on it — pivoting, restructuring, ending — is the action. The action does not stop because one form of it failed.

Seneca, De Tranquillitate 13: the wise man never alters his decision while the conditions under which he formed it remain the same. The conditions have not remained the same. Altering the decision is appropriate, not weakness. The fluency with which you made the original decision should be matched by the fluency with which you update it.

Epictetus, Enchiridion 1: outcomes are not in column one. They never were. The project's success was a hoped-for external. The work you put in is yours forever — it is in your hands as the conduct you brought, the things you learned, the relationships built. None of that is taken by the project failing. What is taken is one external arrangement among many.

What the popular version misses

  • Push through. Discipline equals fortitude. Sometimes. Often it is the opposite — the inability to update on new information is a vice, not a virtue. Stoic eustatheia (steadiness of soul) is not stubbornness; it is stability that can include changing course.
  • Failure is a teacher. Sometimes useful, sometimes a way of dressing the thing in dignity it does not yet have. The Stoic does not require the failure to be retrospectively educational. The Stoic absorbs it, acts on it, continues.

The commitment

This week, make the decision. Not next month. Not after one more sprint. Decide. Continue with a clear-eyed reset, change shape, or end. The work that is appropriate now requires the decision to be made; deferring it is itself the failure mode. The decision will be wrong in some respects; that is the nature of decisions made with incomplete information. Make it anyway and act on it. The relief of having made it is part of how you know it was overdue.